Revolution

5 Oct

Andi Alpers has lost her family – her mother to mental illness, her father to his new life, and her brother to death – and is close to losing herself. She is depressed and at risk of being expelled from school. Andi takes medicine to help ease her pain, but music is what brings her the most relief. Her geneticist father returns one day and drags her away with him to Paris where he has work to do and where he hopes that Andi will be able to focus her energy on writing her senior thesis outline. Her Parisian historian host, G, gives her an antique guitar and within its case she finds the diary of a young woman, Alexandrine Paradis, who lived over two centuries ago during the French Revolution. Alex was a theater performer who dreamt of the big stage. She thought she had found her in when she caught the attention of the royal family and was hired to be a companion to the young prince, Louis Charles. When the royal family was imprisoned and the young prince locked away in a tower prison, Alex realized that there was a far more important and dangerous role that she must play. As Andi reads Alex’s words she is captivated by her story and feels a connection with Alex that becomes even more real during a late night party in the catacombs of Paris.

I felt invested in both of the main characters in this novel – Andi and Alex. Andi has no clear life plans, perhaps because she cannot allow herself to dream of living with the guilt she feels at the death of her brother. Alex had big plans for herself, but they were sidestepped when she realized that her love for the young prince was more important. Both find themselves in a crucial moment in their lives and traumatized by the cruel events they have witnessed in life. Both women are talented performers, both see dead people, both are heartbroken by what has been done in the name of revolution to young men who they loved. Andi is, like her host Lili says, “a ghost….Almost gone.” (p. 79) For a character who is so lost, the reader is still able to see through her ghostly facade. We can see her in her friendship with Vijay, her growing relationship with Virgil, her connection with Alex, her love of music, and her sadness in her loss.

While I am not a huge fan of historical fiction, I must say that the diary portions of this novel sucked me in as much as they did for Andi. I found it hard to imagine Andi ever being able to put the journal down, as it was immensely hard to put this novel down myself. I suppose in both of our cases, deadlines sometimes get in the way of our passion for stories. The journal entries did not always read as I am accustomed to personal accounts reading, but I was so enthralled by the stories that it didn’t bother me. I decided that I was satisfied with my reasoning that Alex as a performer would have a different way of conveying her story than your typical journaler.

The story also speaks to the therapeutic power of music. Andi’s music teacher encourages her to use music to help her survive her grief – “one note at a time.” (p. 95) And it is when Andi is performing music that we see her at her happiest and most social. Her unintended love interest in the story makes his living as a taxi driver but lives for his music. Virgil is the most attractive love interest that I’ve come across in a novel in a long while. I love him. Seriously. He can borrow my iPod anytime. The novel is so filled with music, that I couldn’t help but make a mix. Missing from the mix of course is the music of Amadé Malherbeau who Andi is writing her thesis on – he does not exist, a fact which does not in any way help to quell my longing to hear his Fireworks Concerto.

I love the commentary in Revolution about history versus science. This debate is centered around a human heart that Andi’s father is conducting DNA tests on and that is believed to be the heart of Louis Charles. Her father believes the human heart is made up of proteins and that science is truth because it relies on fact rather than interpretation. G believes the human heart is made up of stories and argues that science can only tell us what we are, not who we are – that what gives something meaning isn’t its genetic breakdown but because of its context, because of stories, because of what it tells us about society and of ourselves. Donnelly also brings up the concept of the agency of the reader and how our lives affect our understanding of history. Andi’s father relates to the King and Queen as a parent who can’t imagine having to leave his children behind in such a brutal world, while Andi relates to Alex as a young woman tasked with caring for a child who she loved deeply and could not save from the cruelty of others.

In the end, perhaps the biggest questions that Donnelly asks are about ideals and revolution and the ever-present brutality in our world. She asks, do the ideals of revolution justify its violent means? How can a people fight for liberty, equality, and fraternity while depriving certain citizens of those basic rights? Is it possible to build a better world on a foundation of brutality? Is any ideal ever worth the life of a child?

I could say that I recommend Revolution to lovers of music and historical fiction (which I do), but that is not enough. The story is an impressive blend of contemporary fiction and historical fiction, with heart-wrenching character development. Donnelly’s musical references awaken the auditory system for anyone with a strong internal jukebox. She raises thought-provoking questions and makes the reader wish that they could change history. Revolution will be released on October 12th and I encourage anyone who loves a great story to be in line with me that day purchasing a copy.

Em’s rating: 5 out of 5 stars
Author: Jennifer Donnelly
Publisher: Delacorte Press (2010)

Note: Advanced Reader Copy sent from publisher.

Special thanks to Suzanna Hermans of Oblong Books and Music for recommending this title!

16 Responses to “Revolution”

  1. Ralph Johnson 05. Oct, 2010 at 2:35 am #

    Wow, great review of a truly great book. LOVE the mix! Thanks!!

  2. Erin 05. Oct, 2010 at 9:31 am #

    Wow. Okay, I love music, historical and contemporary fiction, and great character development. I can’t wait to read this book!!

  3. Meredith 05. Oct, 2010 at 10:23 am #

    This book caught my eye and I’ve been wondering about it. I knew the basics (dual stories, history, etc) but I’m a little surprised (in a good way) to see the history versus science theme. I’m now even more interested in reading Revolution.

  4. Jeannine M. 05. Oct, 2010 at 10:44 am #

    I’m not a big historical fiction girl but this one does seem intriquing. Not to diss YA but this book sounds so deep and heavy I’m surprised it isn’t an adult read. Sounds like a good book to expand my reading horizons.

  5. Melissa Walker 08. Oct, 2010 at 1:52 pm #

    I really, really loved this book–and you reviewed it so well! Jennifer Donnelly is amazing.

  6. Candace 08. Oct, 2010 at 10:44 pm #

    Wow! What a great review! I’ve seen this around on people’s blogs but it hadn’t really caught my attention until I read your amazing review. It sounds like a beautiful story that I will certainly have to read!

    Visiting from Saturday Situation, thanks for linking with us again!

  7. Orchid 09. Oct, 2010 at 12:06 am #

    I saw Revolution online and thought it sounded like an interesting read, but now I’d really like to red it. Thanks for the great review. ^_^

    Visited from the Saturday Situation.

  8. Alessandra 09. Oct, 2010 at 12:13 pm #

    Hi, I’m coming here from The Saturday Situation link-up from Candace’s Book Blog :)

    Wow. Love the cover. Also, the book trailer is very, very intriguing!

  9. brandileigh2003 10. Oct, 2010 at 8:26 pm #

    I love when I can connect with the main character!
    This also sounds like something I would enjoy because I am into the darker fiction (depression, etc)

    Visiting from Saturday Situation!
    Brandi from Blkosiner’s Book Blog

  10. Cass 11. Oct, 2010 at 9:40 am #

    I came from Staruday Situation hosted by Candace’s Book Blog and Pure Imagination.

    YAY! I’m ecstatic that you loved Revolution! I really was pulled in by the cover/s and the premise of the novel. I’m glad that it fit to your standards

  11. Cherry Mischievous 12. Oct, 2010 at 3:00 pm #

    I came from the Saturday Situation hosted by Candace’s Book Blog and Pure Imagination.

    I am not a huge historical fan… but you make this book sound such a good read that I might just have a little nosey…

    Hey, this book releases today!

  12. Nancy B 10. Feb, 2011 at 12:27 pm #

    If you loved this book, be sure to see Neil Shea’s article “Under Paris” in the February 2011 issue of National Georgraphic, pp.104-125. Stephen Alvarez’ pictures are great. I especially loved seeing the beach that was mentioned in the book.

Trackbacks and Pingbacks

  1. Community Review: Revolution « The BookKids Blog! - 13. Oct, 2010

    [...] Love YA Lit [...]

  2. Synchronicity & Books w/ Beat | Love YA Lit - 22. Oct, 2010

    [...] a book that I am listening to in the car or on my iPod. Earlier this month two of these books were Revolution and The Perks of Being a Wallflower, both of which prominently feature [...]

  3. Revolution, Jennifer Donnelly « Jenny's Books - 06. Nov, 2010

    [...] in Books Fyrefly’s Book Blog Good Books & Good Wine Scribbles Killin’ Time Reading Love YA Lit The Fourth Musketeer Book [...]

  4. Revolution | One More Page - 09. Sep, 2013

    [...] reviews: The Guardian Love YA Lit Steph Su [...]

Leave a Reply